Taylor Frankie Paul, known for her role in The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives and the recently withdrawn season of The Bachelorette, will not face charges following recent altercations with her ex-partner, as confirmed by the Salt Lake County District Attorney’s Office on Tuesday.
Authorities in the Salt Lake City suburbs of Draper City and West Jordan have been looking into allegations of domestic violence made by Paul’s former partner Dakota Mortensen, who is the father of her two-year-old son. Paul has also accused Mortensen of misconduct, but those claims were not included in the official documents.
Any new charges against Paul would have breached her probation, which originated from a 2023 incident involving an assault on Mortensen.
The two have submitted competing requests for protective orders against each other, which will be addressed in an upcoming court hearing.
In a memo explaining the decision not to file charges, Breanne Miller, an attorney with the district attorney’s Family Protection Unit, stated, “Several incidents that were submitted do not meet the threshold for criminal offenses. The remaining incidents lack adequate evidence to warrant criminal charges.”
-
ABC cancels Bachelorette season with Taylor Frankie Paul, citing 2023 video
-
Commotion
Why did The Bachelorette cast Taylor Frankie Paul?
Miller pointed out that some of the incidents reported occurred over three years ago and were therefore beyond the legal timeframe for consideration.
The dismissal of charges does not directly impact Mortensen’s protective order against Paul, which has been provisionally granted and may be extended during a hearing on April 30. However, the absence of prosecution could assist Paul and her legal team in presenting their case to a court commissioner, who previously mandated that Paul could only have supervised visits with her son.
At an April 7 hearing, Paul’s attorney Eric Swinyard contended that Mortensen was the instigator in a February confrontation, which he referred to as “the truck tussle.”
In his request for a protective order, Mortensen claimed that Paul threw a drink at him during their argument in a truck to avoid waking the sleeping children inside her home. However, Swinyard alleged that Mortensen slammed Paul’s head against the dashboard and struck her on the leg, presenting photographs of her bruises as evidence.
A separate altercation between the couple in 2023 led ABC to take the unusual step of shelving a season of The Bachelorette that had already been filmed after footage from the incident surfaced last month.
The footage reportedly showed Paul hitting, kicking, and throwing chairs at Mortensen while her young daughter witnessed the distressing scene. Paul was charged with aggravated assault and other offenses, including domestic violence in front of a child. She entered a guilty plea to an assault charge, which can be downgraded from a felony to a misdemeanor if Paul remains free of legal issues during a three-year probation period ending in August. The other charges were dismissed.

Paul, fourth from left, is seen with her fellow co-stars of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives at the Los Angeles premiere for its second season on May 9, 2025. (Araya Doheny/Getty Images)
Eleven incidents between Paul and Mortensen are being scrutinized in relation to their requests for protective orders.
A court-appointed attorney representing their son, Ever, mentioned that another video from May of the previous year depicts Paul pushing Mortensen while yelling at him to leave her house, even though he was holding their child. The attorney, Michael McDonald, expressed concern during the April 7 hearing, stating, “that makes me very nervous about her ability to control herself.”
Paul’s lawyer contended that Mortensen intentionally provoked the situation by using their child as a “human shield.” Conversely, Mortensen’s attorney, Daniela Diaz, claimed that Paul manipulates their son “as a pawn to incite arguments.”
The tumultuous relationship between the couple was prominently featured on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives since its debut in 2024, which played a significant role in Paul’s rise to reality TV fame. The series premiere included police body camera footage of her arrest in 2023.

